Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman – Book vs TV Show Review

Reviews 12 Comments

My review may contain minor, UNMARKED spoilers for the TV show. These spoilers will be minor events that occur in the beginning or middle episodes. Anything major, or anything that happens towards the end will be placed inside spoiler tags.
Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman – Book vs TV Show Review

Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman
Published by: Spiegel & Grau on April 6th 2010
Genre: Adult, Crime, Memoir, Non-Fiction
Pages: 322
Source: Purchased
Buy the Book | Goodreads
My Rating: 2.5 Stars

When federal agents knocked on her door with an indictment in hand, Piper Kerman barely resembled the reckless young woman she was shortly after graduating Smith College. Happily ensconced in a New York City apartment, with a promising career and an attentive boyfriend, Piper was forced to reckon with the consequences of her very brief, very careless dalliance in the world of drug trafficking.

Following a plea deal for her 10-year-old crime, Piper spent a year in the infamous women’s correctional facility in Danbury, Connecticut, which she found to be no “Club Fed.” In Orange is the New Black: My Year in a Women’s Prison, Piper takes readers into B-Dorm, a community of colorful, eccentric, vividly drawn women. Their stories raise issues of friendship and family, mental illness, the odd cliques and codes of behavior, the role of religion, the uneasy relationship between prisoner and jailor, and the almost complete lack of guidance for life after prison.

Compelling, moving, and often hilarious, Orange is the New Black sheds a unique light on life inside a women’s prison, by a Smith College graduate who did the crime and did the time.

If you decide to read Orange is the New Black because you love the TV show, turn back now. That’s what I did. Let’s first talk a bit about the TV show and what it’s all about:

  • The TV show portrays prison as being scary and potentially dangerous.
  • Piper gets “starved out” (denied food) by the inmates who work in the kitchen.
  • The TV show is filled with sex and drugs.
  • The COs are extremely corrupt. They put people into the SHU for almost no reason, they assault women, they smuggle drugs into the prison, etc.
  • There is a lot of relationship drama between Piper and her fiancé Larry. They both struggle with the separation and long distance, and then things get worse when Piper realizes that Alex (her ex-girlfriend, the one who got her into drug trafficking) is in prison with her. Piper has a bit of a lesbian affair with Alex and that obviously puts a strain on her relationship with Larry.
  • Tons of drama between the prisoners as well. Grudges, stalking, harassment, and even murder attempts.

Orange is the New Black the book has almost none of those things.

The book sends a very different message about women’s prison. It almost seems to say, “Women band together and support each other in prison,” which is NOT what the TV show conveys. As soon as Piper stepped into prison (in the book), I knew it was vastly different from the TV show. Left and right women were welcoming her, asking her if she was okay, and giving her “welcome gifts” (shampoo, etc.). Literally not a single inmate was mean to Piper (or anyone, really).

I know the fact that the women were all nice to each other is supposed to be a good thing, since this is a memoir. Speaking in terms of real life, it’s great that women support each other in prison, but the lack of drama does make for a less interesting story. (And I feel terrible to be basically saying, “Your life isn’t an interesting story,” but I don’t know how else to put it…)

One of the biggest differences between the book and TV show is that Alex (named Nora in the book) isn’t even in prison with Piper at all View Spoiler » . As expected, this cuts out a lot of the intensity and drama, and it means there are basically zero relationship problems between Piper and Larry. I’m sure the separation was hard on them, but there were no doubts or moments where they thought their relationship wouldn’t make it (at least none that were conveyed in the book).

While I did enjoy reading Orange is the New Black to get a bit more background information on Piper’s situation, I didn’t find the book to be that entertaining. Although, I guess since the book is a memoir, it is supposed to be more informational than entertaining (is it?). The book is almost written in a diary entry style. It’s not really a “from beginning to end” type narrative; it’s a collection of entries that describe events. But there were long periods of time where I felt like nothing interesting was happening and it was just another “not so bad” day in prison. The book seriously lacked conflict because everyone in prison was just so damn nice, and as a result, I got a bit bored.

Ultimately, I just went into the book for the wrong reasons. I got hooked on the drama from the TV show and was hoping the book would show me how bits of that panned out… like that crazy cliffhanger at the end!! View Spoiler » But there is almost ZERO connection between the TV show and the book, except for the very vague, overall story of a woman going to prison for a 10-year-old drug crime.

The TV Show: I recommend it!

The TV show is interesting and full of drama. There is quite a bit of nudity and sexual scenes, so it’s not for the faint of heart. But it’s interesting, addictive, and loaded with prison scandals and relationship problems.

The one downside is that the Piper portrayed in the TV show isn’t always the most likable person. My boyfriend and I often yelled at her for making stupid decisions that could result in her getting more time added onto her sentence (how stupid could she be??). View Spoiler »

The Book: don’t read it for entertainment

The book lacks conflict and entertainment value. If you’re interested in a fairly detailed account of what prison life is like for women, give it a read, but don’t go into it expecting it to be anything like the TV show. There are no scandals, there’s no drama, there’s no lesbian love affair (in fact there’s zero sexual activity), there are no COs smuggling drugs into prison, and Piper and Larry’s relationship holds up just fine.

The Verdict

okay

12 Responses to “Orange is the New Black by Piper Kerman – Book vs TV Show Review”

  1. Stormy @ Book.Blog.Bake.

    Hmm, that’s so interesting that the show & book are so different. You would think they would have just made an entirely new show in that case rather than try to loosely base it on the book. I’ve never seen the show, but I thought about giving it a chance(still iffy about that part). I’ve been interested in the book, too, but now that I know they’re so different I may reconsider.
    Stormy @ Book.Blog.Bake. recently posted..It’s Book.Blog.Bake. De-Lurking Day{A Party!}My Profile

  2. Ashley R

    My girlfriend highly recommended me to watch this show on Netflix. I had no idea it was even based on a book. But it seems most books-turn-movies are swaying a lot from the actual books these days. Look at what has happened with True Blood. Seasons one and two I liked the show better…then it kinda lost me and I liked the books better again. The movie industry destroyed Twilight (in my opinion) and I’m nervous about the upcoming Vampire Academy—which I’m an even bigger fan of. I love Richelle Mead and she was one of my inspirations to move forward and finish my first book. :-)

    Hope you are doing well and enjoying London. It’s hotter than Haites here in Orlando. Just got back from San Diego and I wish I was still there. We stayed in Coronado this time…loved it. Next trip is Carlsbad, Delmar and some surrounding areas :-)

    ~AR
    Ashley R recently posted..New Release By Jessi Gibson—Dressed In WhiteMy Profile

    • Ashley

      That is an excellent point Ashley, and you’re so right! I actually haven’t read Vampire Academy (eeks!) but I’ve seen a lot of people getting nervous about it for that very reason.

      London is great, thanks! Ohh Colorado! I love it there! And I have some family there too. :) Have fun!!

  3. Kate @ Ex Libris

    The whole idea of this book/show is so interesting to me. I have seen a few episodes and I love the way the characters are written and how we get their back stories.

  4. Kat (AussieZombie)

    I read Orange is the New Black before the TV show began – and honestly, it nearly turned me off watching it (luckily I got bored one day and watched the first episode and realised it was SO MUCH BETTER).

    I didn’t really like Piper at all in the book – I found her quite condescending towards the other prisoners in parts and that was the biggest turn off….
    Kat (AussieZombie) recently posted..Review: Two Boys Kissing by David LevithanMy Profile

    • Ashley

      Yes I totally agree!! Luckily you gave the TV show a shot anyway because I think it’s pretty awesome! But it sucks that the book turned you off it at first. :/ I completely understand why.

  5. Lauren @ Lose Time Reading

    Thanks so much for doing this comparison Ashley! I wanted to read this solely because of the TV show but now I’ve decided to now pick it up. I adored the show but if the book is nothing like it, I’m won’t be picking it up… that’s where the appeal came for me!

  6. Geri

    My daughter and I watched the entire riveting series. We have not read the book, but are very happy to know that the prison was more humane than the show portrayed.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge